Uninsured Crash Claims in Eau Claire, WI: What Injured Drivers Should Know

Driver photographs a damaged vehicle beside a roadside accident scene while holding insurance documents.

If the driver who caused a crash has no insurance, you may still have options for recovering money for injuries and other losses. In Wisconsin, the first places to look are your own uninsured motorist coverage, other available insurance policies, and the state’s safety responsibility process.

The absence of insurance can make a claim more complicated, but it does not automatically mean that an injured person has no remedy.

What should you do immediately after an uninsured-driver crash?

Prioritize safety, medical care, documentation, and a police report. Do not rely on a private promise from the other driver to pay later.

After a crash:

  • Call law enforcement, particularly if anyone is injured, the vehicles are not safely drivable, or the other driver cannot show proof of insurance.
  • Exchange names, addresses, phone numbers, driver’s license information, and vehicle details.
  • Photograph the vehicles, roadway, traffic signs, weather conditions, visible injuries, and any property damage.
  • Get contact information from witnesses.
  • Seek medical evaluation, even if symptoms seem minor. Pain from strains, concussions, and other injuries may become more noticeable hours or days later.
  • Notify your automobile insurance company promptly and state that the crash may involve an uninsured motorist.
  • Keep medical bills, prescription receipts, wage-loss information, repair estimates, and correspondence related to the collision.

Winter conditions, reduced visibility, and slippery roads can complicate disputes about how a crash occurred. Photos and timely witness information may help preserve evidence that becomes difficult to obtain later.

Does Wisconsin require uninsured motorist coverage?

Yes. Wisconsin automobile policies generally must include uninsured motorist coverage for bodily injuries, with minimum limits of $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident.

Uninsured motorist, often called UM coverage, may apply when:

  • The at-fault driver has no required liability insurance.
  • The crash is a hit-and-run and the responsible vehicle cannot be identified.
  • The at-fault driver’s insurer denies coverage because the policy was not active or another coverage issue exists.

UM coverage is primarily for bodily injury. It generally does not pay to repair the vehicle or replace damaged personal property. Vehicle damage may instead involve collision coverage under the injured person’s own policy.

The exact result depends on the policy language, the facts of the collision, and whether the insurer disputes liability or coverage.

What if the uninsured driver caused only vehicle damage?

Uninsured motorist coverage usually does not pay for property damage. If the vehicle is damaged, possible sources of payment may include:

  • Collision coverage, subject to the policy deductible.
  • A claim directly against the at-fault driver.
  • Payment from another responsible party if a separate legal basis exists.
  • Certain other insurance coverages that may apply to specific property or transportation expenses.

If collision coverage pays for repairs, the insurer may seek reimbursement from the responsible driver. The deductible and any remaining loss may still need separate attention.

A lawsuit against the uninsured driver is another possibility, but obtaining a judgment does not guarantee collection. A person may have limited income or assets, making recovery slow or impractical.

Can you make a claim against your own insurance company?

Yes. A UM claim is not the same as claiming that you caused the crash. It is a claim under coverage purchased to protect you and covered household members from injuries caused by an uninsured driver.

The insurance company may investigate:

  • Whether the other driver was uninsured.
  • Who caused the collision.
  • Whether the injuries were caused or worsened by the crash.
  • The amount of medical expenses and lost income.
  • The effect of the injuries on daily activities and future work.
  • Whether another insurance policy may also apply.

The insurer may request medical records, recorded statements, authorizations, employment information, photographs, and other evidence. Before signing broad documents or giving a detailed recorded statement, it is sensible to understand what is being requested and how it may affect the claim.

A disagreement with the insurer does not necessarily mean the claim is invalid. Policy deadlines, notice requirements, settlement provisions, and dispute procedures can matter.

What is the difference between uninsured and underinsured coverage?

An uninsured driver has no applicable liability insurance. An underinsured driver has insurance, but the available policy limits are too low to fully cover the injured person’s losses.

Underinsured motorist coverage, or UIM coverage, may provide additional protection when the at-fault driver’s liability limits are less than the value of the claim. In Wisconsin, UIM coverage is generally optional, and its terms can vary significantly between policies.

For example, suppose an injured person has substantial medical expenses and the responsible driver carries only a small liability policy. A valid UIM claim might provide additional compensation if the injured person purchased that coverage and satisfied the policy requirements.

UM and UIM claims can involve different rules, so the declarations page and the complete policy should be reviewed rather than relying on the coverage name alone.

Personal Injury Attorney photo from Adobe Stock

What role does Wisconsin’s safety responsibility law play?

Wisconsin has a safety responsibility process for crashes involving uninsured motorists. In qualifying situations, an injured person may submit information about vehicle damage, property damage, or personal injury to the Wisconsin Department of Transportation.
The process can lead to licensing or registration consequences for an uninsured driver who does not satisfy responsibility for the crash. The driver may be required to pay, establish a payment arrangement, or provide proof of financial responsibility.
This process is separate from an insurance claim and does not guarantee immediate payment. It is also not a substitute for documenting injuries, notifying an insurer, or evaluating a possible civil claim.
Crash reporting requirements may apply when the collision causes an injury or reaches the applicable property-damage threshold. If law enforcement does not complete the report, a driver may have reporting duties.

Can you sue an uninsured driver?

A person injured by a negligent uninsured driver may be able to file a personal injury lawsuit. Potential damages can include medical expenses, lost wages, reduced future earning ability, pain, disability, and other losses supported by the evidence.
The practical challenge is collection. A court judgment establishes legal responsibility and the amount owed, but it does not necessarily reveal whether the driver has reachable wages, bank funds, property, or other assets.
Before deciding whether a lawsuit is worthwhile, it may be necessary to examine available insurance, household policies, ownership of the vehicle, possible employer involvement, and the driver’s financial circumstances. Legal deadlines also apply, and the deadline can depend on the type of claim and the parties involved.

What mistakes can weaken an uninsured-driver claim?

Several common mistakes create avoidable problems:

  • Waiting too long to report the crash to the insurer.
  • Failing to identify all household insurance policies.
  • Assuming a health insurer or medical provider will handle every expense permanently.
  • Stopping medical care without documenting the reason.
  • Posting statements or photographs that conflict with the injury claim.
  • Accepting money directly from the other driver without understanding whether it releases additional claims.
  • Treating an insurance adjuster’s initial decision as final.
  • Failing to preserve evidence from vehicle damage, roadway conditions, or witnesses.

Residents dealing with a serious injury, disputed fault, a hit-and-run, or a contested insurance claim may need legal guidance to protect deadlines and evaluate all available sources of compensation. The need is especially significant when injuries affect work, require ongoing treatment, or involve permanent limitations.

What records should you keep?

Create a file containing:

  • The crash report and photographs.
  • Insurance declarations pages and claim correspondence.
  • Medical records, bills, and mileage logs.
  • Pay stubs or employer records showing missed work.
  • A daily description of pain, limitations, sleep problems, and treatment.
  • Repair estimates, towing bills, rental-car expenses, and receipts.
  • Names and contact information for witnesses and medical providers.

A complete record helps distinguish immediate expenses from longer-term effects and makes it easier to identify inconsistencies before they become disputes.

Cristina M. Kerr

About the Author

Cristina M. Kerr

Cristina M. Kerr is a personal injury attorney at Bye, Goff & Rohde who represents individuals and families in complex injury and wrongful death cases throughout Wisconsin. She is known for meticulous legal research, trial preparation, and the handling of challenging claims involving government liability, premises liability, and catastrophic injuries, while advocating compassionately for every client.